How to Choose an Ice Machine Rental Company
Most buyers call three rental companies and compare the monthly rate. The lowest cost wins. That strategy only works if monthly rate equals total cost.
But it almost never does. We analyzed 66 rental company websites, scoring each site on 12 questions buyers should have answers to before signing. Half the companies answered four or fewer.
The monthly rate was typically one of those four. The six tips below show how we'd answer the others. We built each tip around the survey results.
1. Work out your own size first, because they will not
Ice companies won't recommend a size for you. Of the 66 websites we reviewed, only 11 (17%) offered any sizing recommendations. And only 29 of the 66 (44%) even tell you what sizes they offer. So you find yourself on a sales call deciding what size to buy. The person suggesting a size is also the person who benefits financially by selling you that size.
Get a sense of what number you should be considering first with our ice calculator. The handful of heuristics floating around on the internet actually agree with each other more than you'd think: three businesses from three different states all independently arrived at 3 pounds of ice per bar seat, two recommend 10 pounds per hospital bed, and restaurant recommendations cluster between 1.5 and 2 pounds per guest.
Once you have a number remember to get a quote for one size larger as well. Smaller machines don't give you very good value for each pound of ice they produce.
A small machine costs about 2.9 times more per pound of capacity than a large one. Four to six rates a band, so read the shape.
We would rather see a business slightly oversized than slightly under. A machine at its ceiling in August fails in August.
2. Start with the companies that publish a price
Publishing a price tells you more than just the price. Of the 69 companies we reviewed, only 16 publish any rate online. Those 16 companies answered an average of 5.94 of our 12 questions compared to 4.00 for the 50 that hide pricing. If a company is willing to publish a number, it's also willing to tell you what term that price is for and how quickly they can deliver. Sorting by publisher will allow you to spend your calls with companies that answer questions.
By contrast, 80% say what the rate includes, 77% name brands. What is easy to say is said. What costs money is not.
Don't filter out with this though. A third of the marketplace is refrigeration shops for whom rental is just a side line business. And of the 34 companies that publish a founding year, the median is 1979. Sometimes a quiet website just means a 47 year old service business that never hired a web marketer. Call them too. And ask them what their website should have told you.
3. Find out what happens when the machine breaks
The question nobody answers upfront and costs you money later is, "How quickly do they respond?" So ask two questions. How quickly does a technician get here when one of your rental machines dies, and do I get ice or a loaner while I wait? Get both in writing (part of the agreement), not an email response.
9%
17%
16%
40 of 69 promise neither. One lease refuses outright: "Complimentary ice delivery is not included in this agreement."
Ask both because they fail in different ways. Fast response with no coverage leaves you purchasing bagged ice for a day. Coverage with no response time leaves you buying it for weeks. Of the companies that actually put commitment in writing, the guarantees are specific. Of those surveyed, seven commit to same-day service, one specifies a four-hour emergency response, ten offer bagged ice, and six will furnish a loaner.
4. Ask for the five facts that set your real cost
Five factors determine how much your rental will cost over three years: minimum term, notice period, self-renewal, early termination fee and annual escalation. Request each factor by name. Seventy percent of providers disclose none.
20%
9%
Not one publishes all five. The two disclosing three or more use PDFs.
If they don't specify, assume three years. Of the 15 that publish a term, eight specify 36 months, four say 12, two six, one month-to-month.
Negotiate most aggressively on the early termination fee, the least commonly published item in our survey and the most expensive if overlooked. Only two providers publish a fee and they couldn't be more different. One charges $400 flat anytime within a year. The other bills twelve months of rent. None publish an annual escalator. Ask if the rate can increase. More in our rental agreement guide.
5. Make them quote one number with every fee in it
A zero-fee quote hides fees. The only service consistently included is repairs: 55 of 69 (80%) cover parts and labour. It goes downhill quickly from there. Installation is "free" for 35%, not mentioned at all for 52%. Filters are included by 26%, not mentioned at all by 65%. And only 23% disclose how frequently they'll clean it.
Out of the 69, forty-seven disclose no charge at any point, which means undisclosed fees, not absent ones. Actual fees we were able to find were all listed by companies that were more transparent: $250 to $500 install fee, $28/month mandatory filter replacement fee, $10 fee to get billed instead of automatically debited from your account. After hours labour at $215/hr. None of these are unreasonable fees. They're hidden by not disclosing unless you specifically ask for "one number, with tax."
6. Verify the licence, then check the site against itself
Two checks. Five minutes each. First verify credentials. They're surprisingly rare in this industry's shop windows. Only 20 out of 66 companies list one. That's 14% claim to be licensed, 8% cite EPA 608, 5% list a numbered state licence to fact check, one in 66 boasts CFESA membership. A numbered licence is exceptionally rare and should be weighted accordingly. If the company lists none, don't be afraid to ask. Whether the site says so or not, the technician opening your sealed refrigerant system should have EPA 608.
Second, read the company against itself. We found page by page a self-contradiction on 19 out of 66 sites (29%): a service described as free on one page and $250 on another, two different founding years, a recommended cleaning frequency opposite to what the company advises you to do. Five sites still use a 2018 copyright. Typically this comes across as neglect, not deception. But the page you clicked on and decided this is the one may not actually be true anymore. Get your quote emailed to you before install day.
How we would decide
| What to ask | A good answer | How rare it is |
|---|---|---|
| Response time and cover | Both, in the agreement | 9% publish both |
| Early-exit penalty | A figure or formula | 8% answer this |
| Term and auto-renewal | In writing, with notice | 27% publish a term |
| All-in monthly cost | One number, tax included | 24% publish a price |
| Cleaning and filters | Twice a year, filters in | 23% state a frequency |
| Credentials | EPA 608 or state licence | 30% name any |
We would take the company that answers all six without friction over the one that is $20 cheaper and vague about the exit. That willingness tells you what a rate card cannot.